Jeff, you probably would prefer pilsners since you haven't had a lot of experience with more robust brews. Something light colored would usually look good for you, but it's not always. For instance, Harp is very light looking but tastes very strong.
I would recommend a Pale Ale to get you accustomed to tastier drinks. I'm having a brain fart atm or I would suggest several. Oh! Sierra Nevada, like Urgon mentioned, is a great beer. Belgian White ales are also light and fruity.
If you prefer something a bit stronger in flavor, I would personally suggest Newcastle or Amstel Light even. Newcastle is especially delicious when layered on top of cider in a giant mug.
If you decide you like the stouter ales, go for a good Oatmeal Stout like Sam Smith. Dead Guy Ale is very stout and a bit sweet, but more of a dessert beer, as is Mackeson's XXX.
Just let me know if you have more questions

Lilae Peutiann - 50 shaman DAoC Galahad
-----------------------------------
Lylae - 60 NE Druid WoW - Kilrogg
http://ctprofiles.net/13573
Lilae - Cow Druid WoW - Kilrogg